Skip to Content

Why Your ERISA Claim May Get Denied

The ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) protects employees participating in employer benefits plans. However, the complexities of the ERISA claim process can often lead to claim denials, leaving many individuals bewildered and frustrated.

Understanding the reasons behind these denials is vital for individuals seeking to navigate the system effectively. This article aims to shed light on the common factors contributing to ERISA claim denials, emphasizing the importance of comprehending the intricacies of the process.

Common Reasons for ERISA Claim Denials

There are various reasons why your ERISA claim may get denied, but some of the most common include:

Lack of Medical Evidence

When filing a claim for disability benefits, medical evidence is key. You’ll need to provide your insurance company with detailed medical records that prove your condition prevents you from working. Your claim may be denied if you fail to provide sufficient medical evidence.

Failure to Meet the Definition of Disability

ERISA characterizes disability as the incapacity to participate in any substantial gainful activity (SGA) owing to a physical or mental impairment. If your condition doesn’t meet this definition, your claim can be denied.

Discrepancies in Your Medical Records

Your insurance company will carefully review your medical records, looking for inconsistencies or discrepancies that suggest you may not be as disabled as you claim. For example, they may look for evidence that you are engaged in physical activities that you claim are impossible due to your condition.

Failure to Meet the Deadline

ERISA requires you to file your claim within a specified period. Not meeting this deadline can lead to the denial of your claim.

Pre-existing Conditions

Claims may also be denied if the insurance provider determines that the condition for which the claim is made is pre-existing. While some plans may cover pre-existing conditions, others may have specific exclusions related to such conditions.

Applicants need to review their plan documents carefully to understand the limitations regarding pre-existing conditions to avoid claim denials based on this criterion.

Failure to Exhaust Administrative Remedies

ERISA also requires that you exhaust all administrative remedies before filing a lawsuit. This means you’ll need to go through your insurance company’s internal appeals process before seeking legal action. If you fail to do so, your claim may be denied.

Should your ERISA claim be denied, you can challenge the decision. Nevertheless, the appeals process can be intricate and lengthy, making it advisable to consult an experienced ERISA attorney for assistance.

Tips for Avoiding ERISA Claim Denials

  1. Ensure the accuracy and completeness of all claim-related information.
  2. Adhere to the stipulated deadlines and submission requirements.
  3. Maintain thorough documentation and provide comprehensive medical evidence.
  4. Understand the specifics of the insurance plan, including its limitations and requirements.
  5. Seek legal advice promptly when uncertainties arise.

The Role of Legal Assistance in ERISA Claims

Navigating the intricate web of ERISA regulations can be overwhelming, particularly for individuals unfamiliar with the legal intricacies involved in the claim process. Seeking professional legal assistance can significantly improve one’s chances of successfully navigating the process. They can help you learn important terms you should know about disability claims.

Legal experts possess a comprehensive understanding of ERISA laws, enabling them to provide invaluable guidance and support throughout the entire claim process. From offering insights into the complexities of the law to representing clients in negotiations and appeals, legal professionals play a pivotal role in ensuring that claimants receive the benefits they rightfully deserve.

Several success stories testify to legal professionals’ critical role in securing positive outcomes for ERISA claimants.


Understanding why your ERISA claim may get denied is the first step in ensuring that your claim is approved. By providing detailed medical evidence, meeting the definition of disability, avoiding discrepancies in your medical records, meeting the deadline, and exhausting all administrative remedies, you can increase your chances of success.


Jeff Campbell