Holiday

Elf on the Shelf is a long-standing Christmas tradition where a family adopts one (or more) elves from Santa to live with them for the holiday season. But if you have more than one kid, is each kid supposed to have an elf?

While each child in a household can have their own individual Elf on the Shelf, many families do indeed choose to just adopt one elf for the family.

That makes it easier on the parents each night when deciding what to make the elves do. And it eliminates potential arguments between children if one elf or elf activity is preferred over another.

But there are other hard and fast rules that should be followed.

In this article, we’ll explore the Elf on the Shelf phenomenon, how many kids have elves, and how parents with multiple elves manage to make it work.

Let’s explore!

What are the Elf on the Shelf rules?

The Elf on the Shelf tradition comes with a few simple rules to make the Christmas magic work. First, the Elf arrives at your house to watch over things and report back to Santa each night. Each morning, the Elf returns and sits in a new spot, waiting to be found by you.

One major rule is that you can’t touch the Elf. Touching the Elf might make it lose its magic, which means it won’t be able to move or go back to Santa. This is why the Elf is usually placed somewhere you can see but not easily touch.

Another rule is that the Elf doesn’t speak or move while anyone in the house is awake. It waits until everyone is asleep to make its move. This adds to the excitement because you never know where the Elf will choose to sit the next morning.

The Elf also needs a name. Giving your Elf a name is part of the fun and helps make him or her a part of your family.

Lastly, the Elf flies back to the North Pole on Christmas Eve to stay with Santa for the rest of the year. This marks the end of the Elf’s visit for that holiday season.

These rules are designed to create a fun and magical experience leading up to Christmas, making each morning an exciting hunt to see where the Elf has decided to sit after returning from the North Pole.

How many kids have an Elf on the Shelf?

As of recent years, the Elf on the Shelf tradition has become increasingly popular, with millions of families participating worldwide.

Specifically, The Lumistella Company, which manages the Elf on the Shelf brand, has reported over 22.9 million Scout Elves, Elf Pets, and Elf Mates adopted globally. This figure underscores the widespread appeal and integration of this festive tradition into holiday celebrations across various cultures and communities.

The Elf on the Shelf phenomenon extends beyond just the figures themselves, encompassing a range of activities and media, including animated specials and various other branded merchandise. This widespread adoption highlights how integral the Elf on the Shelf has become to the Christmas experience for many families, providing a playful way to connect with the holiday spirit.

Why do some kids not have Elf on the Shelf?

Not all kids have an Elf on the Shelf, and there are several reasons why this popular holiday tradition might not be part of every household.

First, cultural differences play a significant role.

The Elf on the Shelf is primarily a Western tradition, particularly popular in the United States. Families from different cultural backgrounds may have their own unique holiday traditions that don’t include the Elf.

Economic factors also influence whether families participate in this tradition. The Elf on the Shelf comes with a cost, not just for the initial purchase but also for the accessories and the time parents need to invest in moving the elf daily. For some families, this expense and the effort aren’t feasible, especially during the holiday season, which can already be a financially demanding time.

Additionally, some parents choose not to introduce the Elf on the Shelf due to the nature of the game itself, which involves the elf watching over the children and reporting back to Santa on their behavior. Some parents disagree with this aspect as they feel it introduces a ‘surveillance’ style of teaching behavior management to children.

Lastly, lifestyle choices and personal preferences dictate whether families adopt this tradition. Some parents might not want to commit to the daily responsibility of moving the elf, or they prefer to focus on other holiday activities that they find more meaningful or enjoyable for their family.

Each family’s choice is often influenced by their values, beliefs, and circumstances, which explains why the Elf on the Shelf isn’t a universal feature in all homes during the Christmas season.

Is it harder for parents to manage moving multiple Elf on the Shelf elves?

Managing multiple Elf on the Shelf elves certainly presents more challenges for parents than just handling one.

Each elf is supposed to have its own unique personality and position each morning, which can require a significant amount of creativity and planning. When there’s more than one elf, parents need to come up with distinct scenarios for each, ensuring they’re placed in different parts of the house to keep the magic alive for each child.

Additionally, the daily commitment increases with each added elf. Parents are responsible for remembering where each elf was the day before and then thinking of a new, engaging spot for it to appear the next day. This can be especially taxing during the busy holiday season when schedules are already packed and parents are managing numerous other holiday tasks.

The logistics of managing multiple elves can also become complex. Parents must ensure that each elf’s story and actions don’t contradict the others, maintaining a cohesive narrative that aligns with the holiday spirit and family traditions. This can turn into a significant nightly effort to keep the story exciting and fresh.

Despite these challenges, many parents find that the joy and excitement these elves bring to their children make the extra effort worthwhile. The elves can encourage creativity in children as they speculate about the elves’ nightly adventures and foster a fun, festive spirit in the home.

However, it’s important for parents to balance the workload with the enjoyment to ensure that the holiday season remains joyful and not overly stressful.

Final Thoughts

Deciding whether each child should have their own Elf on the Shelf ultimately comes down to what works best for your family. There is no hard and fast rule that dictates one elf per child is necessary. Instead, the decision can be shaped by considering your family’s size, the age differences between your children, and your capacity to maintain the tradition effectively.

If managing multiple elves feels overwhelming, remember that the spirit of the Elf on the Shelf is to foster joy and excitement about the holidays. It’s perfectly acceptable to have one elf for the family or multiple elves if it enhances the Christmas magic without adding undue stress.

Consider your children’s personalities and dynamics: some may enjoy the shared excitement of a single elf’s daily adventures, while others might appreciate a more personalized experience with their own elf.

Also, involving older children in the setup for younger siblings can be a fun activity that fosters bonding and keeps the tradition alive as they grow older and learn the secret behind the elf.

I have a collection of free printables for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize them with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there are a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Every year between Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve, countless parents tirelessly move their Elf on the Shelf every night to the delight of their kids. But every once in a while, we slip up. So what should you do if your child sees you move your Elf on the Shelf?

If your child sees you moving the Elf on the Shelf, stay calm, don’t panic, and don’t act caught or flustered. Simply explain that the elf was sick and needed a little extra assistance. Or say that Santa messaged you to let you know the elf was sick and needed a little extra help.

But there’s more to it than that!

Done wrong, your kids will easily see through your charade and know that it’s all been a lie. But they might also be at the right age to come clean anyway.

So in this article, we’ll explore what ages are best for kids to find out the truth and the best way to tell kids that Elf on the Shelf is fake, when you are ready to tell them.

Let’s dive in.

Is there a legitimate reason to tell kids why you moved your Elf on the Shelf?

If your child catches you moving the Elf on the Shelf, it’s natural to feel a bit flustered, but there are legitimate reasons you can offer that maintain the magic of the tradition while being honest.

One approach is to explain that sometimes the Elf needs a little help.

Just like in stories where magical creatures sometimes need assistance from humans (like children leaving out shoes for a cobbler elf or cookies for Santa), you could say that you were helping the Elf get to a new spot because maybe it had trouble deciding where to go next or needed a bit of assistance due to its many travels back and forth to the North Pole.

Another option is to turn it into a playful moment. You can suggest that the Elf was teaching you how to be sneaky and magical, just like it is. This can add an element of fun and conspiracy between you and your child, making them feel part of the magic.

It’s also a chance to instill a lesson about responsibility and caring. Explain that sometimes everyone, even a magical elf, needs a bit of help, and it’s okay to ask for it and give it. This reinforces the idea of teamwork and being there for each other, linking back to the spirit of community and giving during the holiday season.

By addressing the situation directly and creatively, you turn a potentially tricky moment into a positive and memorable part of your holiday tradition.

What age do kids stop believing in the Elf on the Shelf?

Kids stop believing in the Elf on the Shelf around the ages of seven to nine.

At this age range, children’s cognitive abilities are developing rapidly, and they begin to distinguish between reality and make-believe more clearly. They start applying logic to situations that previously were accepted without question, and this is a natural and healthy part of growing up.

Peer influence is significant too.

Children talk, and what they hear on the playground or in school can impact their beliefs about magical traditions like the Elf on the Shelf. If a child has older siblings, they might learn the truth earlier as they observe or overhear conversations.

It’s important to handle this transition sensitively.

When kids start questioning whether the Elf is real, it can be a good opportunity to encourage critical thinking. Ask them what they think and why, and commend them for their thought process, regardless of whether they believe or not. This not only helps in dealing with the specific issue of the Elf on the Shelf but also teaches them valuable reasoning skills.

Remember, even after kids stop believing in the Elf as a magical being, they can still enjoy the tradition and fun of finding the Elf each morning. It turns into a fun family game, maintaining the joy and excitement of the holiday season.

Should I tell my kid Elf on the Shelf isn’t real?

Deciding whether to tell your child that the Elf on the Shelf isn’t real is a personal choice that depends on your family’s values and the specific circumstances.

If your child sees you moving the Elf and asks directly about it, consider their age and maturity before responding. Younger children who are deeply enchanted by the magic of the holiday might benefit from a gentle story that keeps the fantasy alive a bit longer, such as saying the Elf needed help or was playing a game.

For older children who are starting to figure things out, it might be an opportunity to have a more open conversation.

You can ask them what they think and let them lead the discussion. This approach respects their developing critical thinking skills and encourages honesty without directly dispelling the magic. It’s important to gauge their readiness; some kids might be ready to appreciate the fun and tradition behind the Elf without believing it’s real, while others might still cling to the magical aspect.

In any case, emphasize that the spirit of the Elf on the Shelf is about fun and family traditions.

It’s about creating joyful memories and not just about whether the Elf is real or not. Highlight that they can now participate in the tradition by helping younger siblings or cousins continue to believe, thus becoming part of creating holiday magic for others, which can be a very rewarding experience.

How to tell your child Elf on the Shelf isn’t real

Telling your child that the Elf on the Shelf isn’t real can be a sensitive moment.

When deciding to share this, it’s important to consider their age, maturity, and how they might react. If they directly ask you after seeing you move the Elf, it might be time to have the conversation.

First, find a quiet, comfortable moment when you won’t be interrupted. Start by acknowledging their curiosity and praising their observation skills, which shows that they are growing up and can handle more complex truths. You might say something like, “I’ve noticed you’ve been thinking a lot about the Elf. It’s really impressive how much you’re observing!”

Then, gently explain that the Elf is part of a fun game that families play during Christmas.

Emphasize that just like their favorite stories or movies, the Elf is a character that brings joy and fun into the house. You can explain that parents move the Elf around to create a magical story, and now they’re old enough to help continue this tradition if they have younger siblings or cousins.

Assure them that understanding the Elf is a game doesn’t take away from the holiday spirit.

Instead, it’s a new way to enjoy the season by helping keep the magic alive for younger kids. Encourage them to think of it as being part of a special ‘grown-ups’ secret and that they now have an important role in creating holiday magic for others. This approach can help ease the transition and keep the festive fun going.

Final Thoughts

If your child happens to spy you moving your Elf on the Shelf, don’t panic. Resist the urge to spill the beans and disclose that it’s all fake. Remember the whole reason you started this, and countless other traditions, was to foster that childlike innocence in your children. So no need to blow it from a one-time mistake.

Explain that your elf got sick and just needed a little help. Or that Santa messaged you and told you the elf was sick or otherwise needed extra assistance. If they already believe in Santa, the Tooth Fairy, and other holiday myths, they will easily buy a story like that.

But you remaining calm and confident will be what convinces them the most. If you act like a kid who got his hand caught in the cookie jar, they’ll be far more skeptical.

I have a collection of free printables for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize them with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there are a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Elf on the Shelf is a Christmas tradition where a family adopts an elf from Santa. And each night, the elf supposedly flies home to the North Pole to report back to Santa. But are Elf on the Shelf really alive?

Elf on the Shelf are not actually alive. As with Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, and other fictional characters, Elf on the Shelf is a myth created to enthrall and entertain young children and help keep the youthful innocence alive.

Parents typically move the elf each night after the children go to sleep helping to perpetuate the myth that the elves are alive and can move on their own.

That being said, there are some children and parents alike who swear it’s not that simple and that the elves are indeed real and magical.

Read on to dive in deeper on the mystery and decide for yourself.

Is the Elf on the Shelf actually moving?

The Elf on the Shelf isn’t actually moving on its own. It’s a holiday tradition where parents move the elf around the house to create the illusion that it’s alive and watching children to report their behavior to Santa Claus. The elf is just a doll, and it doesn’t have any magical powers to move by itself.

Every night, after the children go to bed, parents move the elf to a new spot in the house. This way, when the kids wake up, they find the elf in a different place, believing it moved on its own. The idea is to keep the magic of Christmas alive and encourage good behavior.

Sometimes, the elf is found doing funny or mischievous things, like making a mess in the kitchen or hiding in the Christmas tree. These scenarios are all set up by the parents. Kids enjoy waking up and searching for the elf’s new hiding spot, and it adds excitement to the holiday season.

While the elf itself doesn’t move, the fun part is the imagination and creativity that goes into setting up these scenes. The Elf on the Shelf tradition is meant to be a playful and magical part of the Christmas experience, even if the elf isn’t really alive or moving on its own. It relies on the parents’ efforts to create the magic for their children.

Do parents move the Elf on the Shelf, yes or no?

Yes, parents move the Elf on the Shelf. The elf itself is just a doll and doesn’t have the ability to move on its own. The idea behind the Elf on the Shelf is to create a fun and magical experience for children during the holiday season. Every night, after the children go to bed, parents move the elf to a new spot in the house.

The next morning, kids wake up excited to find where the elf has moved. This makes it seem like the elf is alive and watching their behavior to report back to Santa Claus. The elf might be found in funny or mischievous positions, like hiding in the Christmas tree, hanging from a light fixture, or even making a mess in the kitchen. These scenarios are all created by the parents.

The purpose of moving the elf is to keep the magic and excitement of Christmas alive for the children. It also encourages good behavior, as kids believe the elf is keeping an eye on them and reporting back to Santa. The parents’ role is crucial in this tradition, as they are the ones who set up the scenes and move the elf each night.

While the elf doesn’t move by itself, the creativity and effort of the parents make the experience special and memorable for the kids. The Elf on the Shelf tradition is a playful and magical part of the holiday season, brought to life by the parents’ nightly efforts.

Does the Elf on the Shelf actually fly?

When thinking about whether the Elf on the Shelf can actually fly, it’s important to consider the role of imagination in the tradition. For children, part of the magic of Christmas and the Elf on the Shelf is believing in the extraordinary, like flying reindeer and, yes, a flying elf.

The story and the idea are that each night, while everyone is sleeping, the Elf flies back to the North Pole to report on the day’s adventures and then returns by morning to a new spot in the house.

From a practical standpoint, however, the Elf on the Shelf does not literally fly.

The Elf is a toy, a character from a book that was created to add a little extra excitement to the holiday season. Parents often move the Elf around when the kids aren’t looking, setting up the scene so that in the morning, it appears as though the Elf has moved on its own.

This creates a fun and engaging way for kids to wake up each morning in December, filled with anticipation to see where their Elf has landed.

In essence, the Elf on the Shelf flying is part of the imaginative play that surrounds Christmas. It encourages creativity and belief in magical possibilities, which are key parts of the holiday spirit for many families. For children, the belief that their Elf can fly enhances their enjoyment and belief in the magic of Christmas, keeping the tradition alive and exciting.

Is the Elf on the Shelf real for adults

As adults, when we talk about whether the Elf on the Shelf is real, we’re entering a different kind of conversation than the one we might have with kids. For children, the Elf is a magical creature that moves around the house, keeping an eye on behaviors and reporting back to Santa. It’s a fun part of their Christmas tradition that adds to the excitement of the holiday season.

For adults, however, we know that the Elf on the Shelf isn’t literally a living creature.

The Elf is actually a part of a Christmas tradition started by a book published in 2005, where parents place the Elf in different spots around the house every night to create a playful environment and encourage good behavior in children. The idea is that the Elf is watching and will report back to Santa who’s been naughty or nice.

In this sense, the Elf on the Shelf for adults isn’t about believing in the Elf as a real entity but about cherishing the joy and the spirit it brings into their homes during the holidays. It’s a tool for creating fun memories and teaching children about rewards, consequences, and festive cheer.

So, is the Elf on the Shelf real for adults? No, not in the literal sense. But does it bring real joy, excitement, and a sense of holiday spirit? Absolutely. In that way, the Elf is very much a part of the reality of Christmas, just through a different, more whimsical lens.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately Elf on the Shelf is a product. Created in recent times and sold and marketed to make money for the concept creators Carol Aebersold and her daughter Chanda Bell.

But like the urban myths about Santa, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and others, the legend of the Elf on the Shelf gets spread and popularized. And it has become a Christmas tradition for hundreds of thousands of families.

And anything that helps spread joy and child-like innocence can’t be all bad, right?

I have a collection of free printables for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize them with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there are a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

It’s that time of year again, when the Elf on the Shelf makes its grand appearance in many homes, delighting children and parents alike. But have you ever wondered, “Why does Elf on the Shelf misbehave?”

This blog post will delve into the reasons behind Elf on the Shelf’s antics, the effects on children’s behavior, and how it might not always be the best way to manage misbehavior. So buckle up and join us on this enlightening journey to discover a fresh perspective on the role of Elf on the Shelf in your child’s life.

Throughout this blog post, we will explore alternative strategies for managing why Elf on the Shelf misbehaves, discuss the importance of balancing fun and discipline during the Christmas season, and introduce you to some wonderful alternatives to Elf on the Shelf that can help nurture positive behaviors in children.

Are you ready to make this holiday season a magical and meaningful experience for you and your child? Let’s dive in!

Short Summary

• Elf on the Shelf can foster imagination and positive behavior in kids, but it’s important to set boundaries.
• Use Elf as a teaching tool to show the consequences of actions & create meaningful holiday experiences.
• Alternatives like Kindness Elves & Gratitude Journals help promote kindness, generosity & appreciation for life!

Understanding Elf on the Shelf Misbehavior

Elf on the Shelf has become a Christmas staple in many households. It all started as a children’s book by Carol Aebersold and her daughter Chanda Bell. It then grew into a Christmas time phenomenon.

Elf on the Shelf is for younger kids ages 3-7 (give or take) and each year, often Thanksgiving eve, the elf flies to your house from the North Pole to start that holiday season.

The elf’s purpose?

To encourage imagination and creativity in children by engaging in a series of mischievous antics throughout the holiday season. While many parents and children find the elf’s antics to be a source of laughter and fun during the Christmas season, it’s essential to understand the impact of Elf misbehavior on children’s behavior and find ways to manage it effectively.

Is telling children their elf friend is a snitch a good idea? Does using Santa’s little helper as a motivational tool actually improve the behavior of younger children?

In the following sections, we will delve deeper into the purpose of Elf Antics and how they encourage imagination in children. We will also discuss the potential effects of Elf misbehavior on a child’s behavior and provide strategies for managing it in a way that fosters creativity and positive behavior.

The Purpose of Elf Antics

Many families enjoy the fun and cheer that Elf on the Shelf brings to their December mornings.

The elf, sent by Santa Claus, performs its elf moves around the house each day, monitoring children’s behavior and reporting back to the North Pole. If your kids are bad, the scout elf tells Santa and your kids could end up on the naughty list.

By maintaining a positive, fun atmosphere, you can ensure that the Elf on the Shelf remains a Christmas tradition for your family during the holiday season.

Encouraging Imagination

The Elf on the Shelf tradition serves to encourage children’s imagination, as they wonder about the elf’s nightly adventures and the magic it possesses.

However, it’s important to be aware of the potential impact this tradition can have on a child’s behavior. Elf on the Shelf could lead to discouragement and anxiety, especially for those who struggle with impulse control or making good decisions.

To maximize the benefits of Elf on the Shelf and minimize its potential negative effects, it’s crucial to strike a balance between nurturing a child’s imagination and promoting good behavior.

By focusing on the elf’s positive attributes and monitoring the child’s reactions, you can ensure that this tradition continues to be a source of fun, excitement, and wonder during the holiday season.

How Elf Misbehavior Affects Children’s Behavior

While Elf on the Shelf is a beloved holiday tradition, it’s important to consider the impact it may have on children’s behavior. In some cases, children may mimic the elf’s misbehavior, making it crucial for parents to set boundaries and use the elf as a teaching tool.

Not only can this help manage the elf’s antics, but it can also teach valuable lessons to children about their own behavior and the natural consequences that follow.

In the following sections, we will explore how children may mirror the elf’s misbehavior and the importance of learning from the elf’s consequences. We will also provide strategies for managing your Elf’s mischievous ideas and pranks, ensuring that both fun and discipline are maintained during the Christmas season.

Mirroring the Elf

Using Elf on the Shelf to shame or manipulate children’s behavior can lead to increased anxiety and aggression. Furthermore, it might teach kids that their behavior should be dictated by rewards, rather than an intrinsic motivation to do what’s right.

To counteract these potential negative effects, it’s essential to establish boundaries with the Elf and use it as a teaching tool to foster positive behaviors. By focusing on the positive aspects of the Elf on the Shelf tradition and using it to teach valuable lessons about consequences and empathy, you can create a more balanced and enjoyable holiday experience for your child.

This will not only help manage the Elf’s misbehavior but also encourage your child to reflect on their actions and the impact they have on others.

Learning from the Elf’s Consequences

If Elf on the Shelf is used to reprimand or control children’s behavior, it could lead to higher levels of anxiety and aggression. Moreover, it may teach kids that the only reason to be good is to get rewards. To avoid these pitfalls, consider using the Elf as a teaching tool to show children how their behavior has consequences and help them think about how their actions may affect others.

Setting boundaries with the Elf, such as not allowing it to be moved or touched, can help manage misbehavior. Furthermore, using the Elf to teach lessons about consequences, responsibility, and empathy can provide a more positive and meaningful holiday experience for your child.

Strategies for Managing Elf Misbehavior

As we have explored, Elf on the Shelf can have both positive and negative impacts on children’s behavior.

To ensure a balanced and enjoyable holiday season, it’s essential to implement strategies that manage Elf misbehavior effectively. By setting boundaries with the Elf, using it as a teaching tool to promote positive behaviors, and fostering a positive environment, you can create a magical and meaningful Christmas experience for your family.

In the following sections, we will delve deeper into specific strategies for managing Elf misbehavior. We will discuss how to set boundaries with the Elf and use it as a teaching tool, as well as the importance of balancing fun and discipline during the Christmas season.

Setting Boundaries with the Elf

Setting boundaries with the Elf on the Shelf is crucial to managing its misbehavior and maintaining a positive holiday atmosphere.

One way to do this is by making the Elf’s purpose more positive than punitive, focusing on reporting good behavior instead of bad. Another approach is to ensure that the Elf’s magic is preserved by handling it with care and placing it in a cool environment, such as the refrigerator, for 30-45 minutes when necessary.

By establishing clear boundaries and expectations, you can ensure that the Elf on the Shelf remains a cherished and positive tradition in your household. This will not only help manage the Elf’s antics but also encourage your child to embrace the spirit of the holiday season and do the right thing well beyond Christmas Eve.

Using the Elf as a Teaching Tool

The Elf on the Shelf can serve as an effective teaching tool to encourage positive behaviors in children. For instance, the Elf can write messages to students or create a ball pit with jelly beans or pom-poms, making learning more engaging and enjoyable.

However, it’s important to be aware of the potential drawbacks of using the Elf as a teaching tool. In some instances, it may be used as a classroom management system, causing anxiety or overwhelm in children.

To get the most out of using the Elf as a teaching tool, it’s essential to strike a balance between fun, engaging activities and promoting positive behaviors. By doing so, you can ensure that the Elf on the Shelf remains a beloved and beneficial holiday tradition for both you and your child.

Balancing Fun and Discipline During the Christmas Season

The Christmas season can be a magical time filled with joy, wonder, and excitement.

However, it’s essential to strike a balance between fun and discipline to ensure a peaceful and enjoyable holiday experience for the whole family. By prioritizing family time and fostering a positive environment, you can create lasting memories and teach valuable lessons to your children during this special time of year.

In the following sections, we will discuss specific strategies to help you balance fun and discipline during the holiday season. We will explore the importance of prioritizing family time and fostering a positive environment, as well as introduce some fantastic alternatives to Elf on the Shelf that can help nurture positive behaviors in children.

Prioritizing Family Time

Making time for family activities during the Christmas season is crucial to creating a positive and memorable holiday experience. By scheduling regular family dinners, game nights, movie nights, or other activities that everyone can enjoy, you can strengthen family bonds and create lasting memories. Additionally, planning special outings or trips together can further enhance the holiday experience and bring the family even closer together.

To ensure that family time remains a priority during the holiday season, it’s essential to set clear boundaries with employers or other commitments, limiting work or other obligations during this time. By planning ahead and delegating tasks, you can ensure that everyone has enough time to spend together and fully enjoy the magic of the Christmas season.

Fostering a Positive Environment

Creating a positive atmosphere during the Christmas season is key to ensuring a joyful and peaceful holiday experience for everyone. Decorating, baking, playing games, and watching holiday movies are all great ways to make the season fun and festive.

Additionally, giving back to the community through volunteering, making donations to charities, or lending a helping hand to neighbors can add a deeper sense of meaning and fulfillment to the holiday season.

By focusing on the positive aspects of the holiday season and engaging in activities that promote kindness, generosity, and gratitude, you can create a nurturing environment that encourages personal growth and the development of strong family bonds. This will not only make the holiday season more enjoyable for everyone, but also provide valuable lessons that will last a lifetime.

Alternatives to Elf on the Shelf

While Elf on the Shelf is a popular holiday tradition, it’s not the only option available for families looking to encourage positive behaviors in children during the Christmas season.

In this section, we will introduce you to two fantastic alternatives to Elf on the Shelf which use positive reinforcements: Kindness Elves and Gratitude Journals. Both of these alternatives focus on nurturing positive character traits and fostering a sense of appreciation and gratitude in children.

In the following subsections, we will explore each of these alternatives in more detail, discussing their benefits and how they can help cultivate positive kids’ behavior in children during the holiday season and beyond.

Kindness Elves

Kindness Elves are a wonderful alternative to Elf on the Shelf that help kids learn to be kind, generous, and thoughtful.

These charming little elf promote positive character-building activities, such as expressing gratitude, performing acts of kindness, and being mindful of their behavior and words. By focusing on these positive attributes, Kindness Elves can help kids develop a strong sense of empathy and understanding of how their actions may affect others.

In addition to teaching valuable life lessons, Kindness Elves can also be used to create fun and engaging activities for kids, such as leaving notes of encouragement, helping with chores, or even leaving small gifts or treats.

By incorporating Kindness Elves into your holiday traditions, you can foster a sense of compassion, generosity, and thoughtfulness in your children that will last well beyond the Christmas season.

CLICK HERE to check them out on Amazon

Gratitude Journals

Gratitude Journals are another excellent alternative to Elf on the Shelf that can help children recognize and express appreciation for the good things in their life. By regularly writing in a gratitude journal, kids can develop a more positive outlook on life, boost their overall well-being, and learn to be thankful for what they have.

Encouraging children to maintain a gratitude journal can serve as a powerful tool for personal growth and reflection. Not only does it help them focus on the positive aspects of their lives, but it also fosters a sense of gratitude and appreciation that can create lasting happiness and satisfaction.

By embracing gratitude journals as a holiday tradition, you can help your child cultivate positive behaviors and attitudes that will enrich their lives for years to come.

CLICK HERE to see a great one for kids on Amazon

Summary

Throughout this blog post, we have explored the impact of Elf on the Shelf on children’s behavior, discussed strategies for managing Elf misbehavior, and introduced you to some wonderful alternatives that can help nurture positive behaviors in children during the holiday season.

By understanding the reasons behind Elf Antics, setting boundaries, and using the elf as a teaching tool, you can create a more balanced and enjoyable holiday experience for both you and your child.

As you prepare for the magical Christmas season, remember that the key to a joyful and meaningful holiday lies in striking a balance between fun and discipline, prioritizing family time, and fostering a positive environment.

By embracing these principles and incorporating alternatives like Kindness Elves and gratitude journals into your holiday traditions, you can create lasting memories and teach valuable lessons that will enrich your child’s life for years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Elf on the Shelf problematic?

Elf on the Shelf can be considered problematic by some parents (and some think Elf on the Shelf is evil) because it encourages children to act in exchange for rewards, like presents at Christmas, which can undermine their internal motivation. It also undermines trust between parents and children by sending the message that lying is acceptable.

Finally, it encourages children to behave based on external incentives rather than developing their own moral compass.

Does Elf on the Shelf misbehave?

Yes, the Elf on the Shelf can misbehave! While the main point of the book is to encourage good behavior among kids, the elf itself often causes a bit of mischief. From making flour snow angels to playing hide-and-seek, it seems the Elf’s own mischievous spirit may be what really appeals to kids!

The Elf on the Shelf is a beloved holiday tradition for many families. It’s a fun way to get kids excited about the holidays and to encourage them.

What does the Elf on the Shelf do when a child misbehaves?

The Elf on the Shelf is traditionally used to remind children to be on their best behavior, with the belief being that he will report back to Santa if they misbehave. So if a child does misbehave, the elf will move around the house in order to keep an eye out for any further misdemeanors.

What is the Elf on the Shelf behavior warning?

Hey parents, is your kid acting out? If so, then it’s time to send them an Elf on the Shelf Bad Behavior Letter. This is a special letter from Santa that reminds children that their actions have consequences and encourages them to make better decisions.

Don’t hesitate to take advantage of this resource to help set your child on the right track.

I have a collection of free printables for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize them with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there are a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right-click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.

When you first buy an Elf on the Shelf, the first thing you notice is the hands are sewn together making certain tasks difficult to mimic when placing your elf doing different activities. So why are Elf on the Shelf hands sewn together?

In this comprehensive blog post, we will explore the reasoning behind this design choice and provide helpful tips for modifying your elf’s hands for increased flexibility.

From hanging elves in different positions during December to ensuring their stability when displayed, there are several factors that contribute to why an Elf on the Shelf’s hands is sewn together. However, with a few simple modifications, you can enhance your elf’s ability to grasp objects and maintain its playful charm.

We’ll guide you through using a seam ripper and needle-nose pliers to create bendable limbs while also offering no-sew alternatives like Velcro strips or magnets. By making these adjustments, not only will your it be more versatile but your Elf on the Shelf will continue to bring even more joy and excitement for your children during the holiday season.

Table of Contents:

• Why Elf on the Shelf Hands are Sewn Together
• Are You Supposed to Take the Elf’s Hands Apart?
• Modify Your Elf’s Hands for More Flexibility
  • No-Sew Alternatives for Flexible Elves
• FAQs
  • Are Elf on the Shelf hands sewn together?
  • How do you get Elf on the Shelf hands to stay together?
  • What is the controversy with the Elf on the Shelf?
  • Does Elf on the Shelf have bendable arms?
• Conclusion

Why Elf on the Shelf Hands are Sewn Together

Elf on the Shelf dolls have their hands sewn together to make it easier for them to maintain their position during the holiday season.

• Easy positioning: Sewn hands allow elves to hang on hooks, shelves, and other areas around your home, making it simple to place them in different spots each day.
• Stability: Connected hands help keep your elf securely in place without falling or losing its grip, ensuring it stays put until you decide to move it again.
• Fun for kids: Hanging elves in various positions throughout December adds excitement for children as they search for them every morning.
• Get creative: With their hands sewn together, elves can be positioned in all sorts of creative ways, adding to the festive atmosphere.
• Design feature: The sewn hands are a deliberate design feature of the Elf on the Shelf dolls, not a mistake or manufacturing error.

So, if you’re wondering why your Elf on the Shelf has its hands sewn together, now you know.

Are You Supposed to Take the Elf’s Hands Apart?

How to Modify Your Elf’s Hands for More Flexibility

Take your Elf on the Shelf ideas to the next level by modifying their hands for increased flexibility and poseability.

• Seam ripper: Carefully remove stitches from each tip of the elf’s hand with a seam ripper for better movement.
• Insert wire: Create more flexible limbs by inserting thin wires into each arm, bending a small loop at the end of the wire before sliding it inside your elf’s arms. Just use wire cutters to snip off any excess length of wire.

With these simple modifications, you can create even more imaginative displays with your Elf on the Shelf during this festive season. It’s just a fun way to have so much fun with your Christmas elf.

And in terms of fooling your kids, bendable, posable arms are a great way to make your Elf on the Shelf seem more real.

But the ultimate accessory for Elf on the Shelf mischievous ideas is ELF FLEX (click to see on Amazon)!

This quickly (and discretely) attaches to your elf to make them:

• • • Bendable
    • Flexible
    • Gripable
    • Hangable

It’s a #1 Best-Seller & Amazon’s Choice Product on Amazon Prime for good reason and at under $15.00, it won’t break the bank either!

No-Sew Alternatives for Flexible Elves

If sewing isn’t your thing, don’t worry – there are still ways to make your Elf on the Shelf more flexible and fun with a sew-free surgery option. Try one of these:

• Velcro strips: Add a small piece of white Velcro to your elf’s palms for easy grasping of objects.
• Magnets: Insert a single magnet into each limb to make your elf cling effortlessly to metal surfaces.

With these simple modifications, your Elf on the Shelf will be posable and ready to add even more excitement and magic to your holiday season by having your elf get into mischief.

Maintaining Holiday Magic with Posable Elves

Spice up your family’s holiday traditions with an adaptable Elf on the Shelf that can bring endless entertainment opportunities and teach children about responsibility during the festive season.

• Encourage good behavior with nightly elf movements: Keep the magic alive by moving your elf each night after the kids have gone to bed, reminding them of the importance of good behavior leading up to Christmas Eve.
• Keep the magical powers alive for children during the holiday season: When all the elves return to the North Pole, it creates a sense of anticipation and wonder for your little ones.

For even more engaging ideas, especially for slightly older kids, check out Pinterest, where you’ll find a ton of great ideas to display your posable elf.

FAQs

Are Elf on the Shelf hands sewn together?

Yes, Elf on the Shelf’s hands are typically sewn together for stability and easier positioning, but you can modify them for more flexibility with the elf’s arm.

How do you get Elf on the Shelf’s hands to stay together?

Attach a small piece of Velcro or small magnets to your elf’s palms or limbs to keep them securely in place. You can sew them by hand, use a sewing machine, or just use fabric glue like this great one from Amazon. If sewing, just use white velcro and white thread for a discrete look. But red thread works too for holiday colors.

A hot glue gun can also work for adhering Velcro to your elf.

What is the controversy with the Elf on the Shelf?

Critics argue that Elf on the Shelf normalizes surveillance culture and raises privacy concerns. But some parents don’t like lying to their kids (and may not teach them to believe in Santa Claus either).

Others still feel like it’s just blatant commercialism designed to sell merchandise at the expense of children’s imagination. And still other parents just think Elf on the Shelf is just downright evil.

Does Elf on the Shelf have bendable arms?

No, traditional Elves don’t have bendable arms, but you can make your own posable elves or buy a flexible version on Amazon. Just click this link to check it out – ELF FLEX (click to see on Amazon)!

That will make your Elf on the Shelf posable.

And if your elf is planning that big day, having bendable, posable arms for your Elf on the Shelf gives you a lot more options when getting married.

Conclusion

Did you know that Elf on the Shelf hands are sewn together for stability during the holiday season?

But fear not, you can still modify your elf’s hands and limbs for a bendable elf using a seam ripper and floral wire or no-sew alternatives like Velcro strips, suction cups, or magnets.

Posable elves are essential for maintaining holiday magic and encouraging good behavior in children.

So whether you keep your elf’s hands sewn together or not, remember to create special memories and traditions with your family during this festive time. It’s just a personal preference.

I have a collection of free printables for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize them with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there are a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Pic of the day: the Elf… by DJ Ghost is licensed under CC2.0 and was cropped, edited, and had a graphic overlay added. and Image by OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.

Everyone knows Elf on the Shelf. And there’s nothing cuter than a couple of scout elves living their lives and making children happy. But can Elf on the Shelf get married?

In this blog post, we delve deep into the world of shelf weddings and proposals, examining various aspects that make these events truly magical.

We will take you through setting up an enchanting Elf on the Shelf proposal scene using heart-shaped candy canes as symbols of love and creating a “she said yes” sign nearby.

Next, we’ll discuss planning the ultimate North Pole wedding by incorporating Santa Claus himself in the ceremony and decorating their getaway vehicle with Hershey kisses trailing behind.

As with any unconventional idea, there is always debate surrounding its acceptance.

We will examine social media reactions to elf marriage proposals and weigh in on balancing creativity and tradition during the Christmas season. Finally, we provide resources for those seeking inspiration for their own creative Elf on the Shelf ideas while still honoring family traditions.

So join us as we answer once more: Can Elf on the Shelf get married? And discover how these whimsical celebrations can bring joy to your home during this festive time of year.

Table of Contents:

• Elf on the Shelf Proposal Scene
• Planning the North Pole Wedding
• The Controversy Surrounding Elf Marriage Proposals and Weddings
• Resources for Creative Elf on the Shelf Marriage Ideas
• FAQs
  • Can Your Elf on the Shelf Get Married?
  • Can an Elf on the Shelf Have a Baby?
  • Is The Elf on the Shelf Real or Is It Your Parents?
  • What Age Is The Elf on the Shelf For?
• Conclusion

How to Create an Elf on the Shelf Proposal

Add some romance to your Elf on the Shelf tradition with a cute proposal scene between two crazy elves – complete with a candy ring pop engagement ring.

• Symbolize their love: Use heart-shaped candy canes to represent the couple’s affection for each other.
• Make it official: Create a “she/he said yes” sign using paper and markers to display near your newly engaged elves.

Creating an Elf on the Shelf marriage proposal can be a fun and memorable way to elevate the normal Elf on the Shelf mischievous ideas during the holiday season.

Here are some steps to help you plan this magical moment:

1. Choose the perfect day:

Pick a date close to the proposal day and secretly set up the scene the night before.

2. Set up a cozy setting:

Decorate a magical spot, like by the Christmas tree or in the living room, with twinkling lights and festive decorations.

3. Use enchanting props:

Add tiny props, like a tiny engagement ring box, a handwritten proposal letter, or a small sign that says “Will you marry me?”

4. Pose the elves:

Position your boy elf and girl elf in a loving pose, perhaps one elf holding a ring or bending down on one knee.

5. Capture the surprise:

Make sure to have a camera ready to capture the joy on your kid’s faces when they discover the special proposal scene in the morning.

6. Make it personal:

Include personal touches that reflect their favorite colors, songs, or shared memories.

7. Keep it playful:

Remember to maintain the fun and magical spirit of Elf on the Shelf while expressing the love and commitment between the elves.

8. Plan for the celebration:

After the proposal, have a plan ready to celebrate their engagement together as a family.

Remember, the most important thing is to create a moment full of love and excitement that your children can cherish. Enjoy this special time together!

Planning a North Pole Wedding for Your Elf on the Shelf Elves

Why settle for a boring wedding when you can plan a magical North Pole wedding for your Elf couple?

• Enlist other toys like Barbie dolls or Frozen characters as guests attending their big day.
• Use Puffs Plus tissues as makeshift gowns for bride-to-be Sparkle.
• Incorporate Santa Claus himself in the ceremony.
• Decorate their getaway vehicle with Hershey kisses trailing behind.

Make this event extra special by adding personalized touches that reflect your family’s unique holiday traditions.

• Include a mini Christmas tree adorned with ornaments representing each member of your household.
• Have elves exchange vows over a plate of freshly baked cookies.

For more inspiration, check out these Christmas wedding ideas and start planning your Elf couple’s dream wedding.

The Controversy Surrounding Elf Marriage Proposals and Weddings

While incorporating Elf On The Shelf figurines into your Christmas Eve celebrations may seem charming, not everyone approves of using them for proposals or weddings due to past instances of online ridicule.

• Social media reactions: Unconventional proposals involving scout elves have received mixed responses on platforms like Facebook and Instagram, with some finding them adorable and others arguing they detract from the true meaning of the holiday season.
• TikTok video – If you search “Elf on the shelf gets married” on TikTok you see that gets over 8 million searches and has a ton of videos that match that title. So clearly people are marrying off their elves!
• Balancing creativity and tradition: It’s important to strike a balance between introducing new concepts like elf marriages while still respecting traditional values during this special time of year; consider discussing these ideas with family members before implementing them in your home.

Resources for Creative Elf on the Shelf Marriage Ideas

Make your Elf on the Shelf experience unforgettable by exploring free printables, online stores, and social media platforms for inspiration.

• Get inspired by fellow parents: Check out Pinterest boards, Instagram hashtags, and Facebook groups for creative ideas and setups.
• Personalize your elf marriage celebrations: Incorporate elements from your own wedding or cultural customs to create a meaningful connection between generations.
• Stay up-to-date with new concepts: Sign up for free printables welcome emails or visit online stores dedicated to providing Elf on the Shelf ideas each holiday season.

These resources will ensure that your young children continue enjoying Elf on the Shelf year after year.

@mandykj

Naughty Elf and his Punjabi Bride #elfontheshelf #naughtyelf #punjabibride #punjabiwedding #sikhwedding #sangna #indianwedding #indianbride #indianelf

♬ Tera Mera Viah – PRIYA

FAQs

Can Your Elf on the Shelf Get Married?

Your Elf on the Shelf can get married for some festive fun, but it’s not part of the official Elf on the Shelf lore, so don’t take it too seriously. Check out Pinterest for some creative inspiration and fun ideas.

Then the anniversary of their wedding from last Christmas can become a new family tradition.

Can an Elf on the Shelf Have a Baby?

An Elf on the Shelf cannot officially have a baby, but you can still create imaginative scenarios involving elf babies to add some excitement to your holiday traditions. Explore Instagram for some ideas.

Is The Elf on the Shelf Real or Is It Your Parents?

The Elf on the Shelf is a fictional character from a popular children’s book series created by Carol Aebersold and Chanda Bell, and parents typically move and pose these scout elves each night during December as part of their family’s Christmas tradition.

What Age Is The Elf on the Shelf For?

The Elf on the Shelf tradition is recommended for children aged 2-12, but families with older kids can still enjoy the playful element of this holiday tradition. Visit the official Elf on the Shelf website for tips tailored to different ages.

Conclusion

Yes, your Elf on the Shelf can tie the knot and have a North Pole wedding with a little imagination and creativity.

Make the celebration unique by incorporating family traditions and balancing creativity with tradition during the holiday season.

Need inspiration? Check out various websites and social media platforms for ideas on how to make your elf marriage celebration special.

From including Santa Claus in the ceremony to decorating your getaway vehicle with Hershey kisses, the possibilities are endless.

I have a collection of free printable Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize it with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there’s a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Image by OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay and 2012 Elf on the Shelf – Snowy by Mark Baylor is licensed under CC2.0 and was cropped, edited, modified, and merged with another graphic

Is Elf on the Shelf just an annoying marketing ploy designed to generate millions in sales at the expense of parents? After all, it leaves many parents exhausted trying to come up with new ideas, and feeling guilty if they forget. So are Elf on the Shelf evil?

In this comprehensive blog post, we will delve into various aspects of the Elf on the Shelf phenomenon to provide you with valuable insights and perspectives.

We’ll explore how incorporating these mischievous elves into your holiday celebrations can foster creativity through belief in magic while also encouraging critical thinking skills in children. Additionally, we’ll discuss using Elf on the Shelf as a behavior management tool by examining its pros and cons, as well as suggesting alternatives to relying solely on elf-based discipline.

Moreover, our exploration will cover ways to incorporate positive messages into your family’s tradition by sharing examples from different families and offering tips for creating your own meaningful version.

Furthermore, we’ll address adapting Elf on the Shelf to reflect cultural diversity and values by selecting culturally representative elves and crafting inclusive stories around them.

So join us as we take an in-depth look at this fascinating topic: Are Elf on the Shelf evil?

First let’s look at the . . . 

11 Reasons Why Elf on the Shelf is Considered Evil By Some

1. Intrusion of Privacy

Some parents dislike Elf on the Shelf because they feel it intrudes on their family’s privacy. They find the idea of a doll watching their every move and reporting back to Santa to be invasive and unsettling.

2. Added Stress and Pressure

Elf on the Shelf can add unnecessary stress and pressure for parents who feel obligated to come up with creative and elaborate ideas every night. It can become a time-consuming and exhausting task, adding to the already busy holiday season.

3. Unattainable Expectations

Many parents feel that Elf on the Shelf sets unrealistic expectations for children’s behavior during the holiday season. They worry that it places too much emphasis on being “good” to receive gifts from Santa, rather than fostering genuine kindness and generosity.

4. Commercialization of Christmas

Some parents believe that Elf on the Shelf contributes to the commercialization of Christmas by turning it into a marketing opportunity. They feel that the focus should be on the real meaning of Christmas rather than a product.

5. Reinforcement of Surveillance Culture

Elf on the Shelf can reinforce a culture of surveillance, where children may feel constantly monitored and judged. This can detract from the idea of fostering trust and open communication within the family.

After all, the Elf of the Shelf is supposed to report back nightly to Santa about both good and bad behavior.

6. Sleep Disruptions

Parents often find themselves staying up late to strategically move the elf, which can disrupt their own sleep patterns. This added exhaustion can take away from the joy of the holiday season.

7. Potential for Misbehavior

Some children may see the mischievous antics of the elf as permission to engage in similar misbehavior. This can create challenges for parents in maintaining discipline and reinforcing positive behavior.

8. Cultural and Religious Sensitivities

Elf on the Shelf’s association with Christmas may not align with the cultural or religious beliefs of all families. Some parents may feel uncomfortable incorporating a Christmas-centric tradition into their household. A belief in Santa Claus, the North Pole, etc is central to supporting the ideas behind the Elf on the Shelf idea.

9. Lack of Inclusivity

Elf on the Shelf’s focus on Christmas may exclude families who celebrate other holidays during the winter season. This can leave some children feeling left out or less valued in the festive atmosphere.

10. Cost and Consumerism

Parents may dislike Elf on the Shelf due to the additional cost associated with purchasing the elf and its accompanying accessories. They may also see it as another example of consumerism, where unnecessary products are marketed to parents.

11. Dislike of Lying to Children

Some parents don’t like to lie to their kids, even if it’s so-called traditions like Christmas, Santa, the Tooth Fairy, etc.

So for a parent that already aligns with that philosophy (I feel sorry for their kids having such a humorless, bore of a parent, lol), they aren’t exactly looking for a new way to lie to their kids about Elf on the Shelf being “real”.

Additional Table of Contents:

• The Impact of Elf on the Shelf on Children’s Beliefs
• Elf on the Shelf: A Behavior Management Tool or Not?
• Adapting Elf On The Shelf To Reflect Cultural Diversity And Values
• Is Elf on the Shelf Right for Your Family?
• FAQs in Relation to Are Elf on the Shelf Evil
  • Is Elf on the Shelf a bad idea?
  • Why are they banning Elf on the Shelf?
  • Does the Elf on the Shelf watch you?
• Conclusion

The Impact of Elf on the Shelf on Children’s Beliefs

Is Elf on the Shelf promoting gullibility or fostering creativity in children? Psychology Today suggests that believing in magical beings like elves can actually enhance imagination and curiosity in young minds.

Fostering Creativity Through Belief in Magic

Encouraging a belief in magic can lead to increased imaginative play, which has been linked with improved cognitive development, according to Parents Magazine.

Encouraging Critical Thinking Skills

However, it is important to balance creative thinking with skepticism and critical thinking skills, as NPR warns that Elf on the Shelf may inadvertently teach children to accept surveillance and blind obedience.

Elf on the Shelf: A Behavior Management Tool or Not?

Is using Elf on the Shelf as a behavior management tool during the holidays a good idea or not?

The Pros and Cons of Elf-Based Discipline

• Pro: Elf on the Shelf encourages good behavior in children by promising rewards from Santa.
• Con: It may lead to kids behaving only for the sake of gifts, rather than understanding the importance of good behavior.

Alternatives to Elf-Based Discipline

If you’re worried about relying solely on your elf for discipline, try incorporating other strategies like positive reinforcement or setting clear expectations for appropriate behavior during the holidays.

Check out these discipline techniques without yelling or spanking for more ideas:

1. Positive Behavior Jar

The Positive Behavior Jar is a fun and interactive alternative to Elf on the Shelf.

Instead of relying on a doll, this approach involves a jar filled with small rewards or privileges. Whenever a child displays positive behavior or accomplishes a specific goal, they can choose a reward from the jar. This system promotes self-motivation and allows children to directly benefit from their own actions.

2. Responsibility Chart

A Responsibility Chart is a visual tool that helps children track and develop good habits. It can include tasks such as completing chores, homework, or practicing good manners. Children earn points or stickers for each task completed, and when they reach a certain number, they can receive a reward or special privilege.

This approach encourages a sense of responsibility and helps children develop a routine.

3. Behavior Bucks System

The Behavior Bucks System is a creative way to encourage positive behavior.

Children can earn “behavior bucks” for tasks like following instructions, demonstrating kindness, or completing responsibilities. These bucks can be collected and exchanged for rewards or privileges, such as choosing a family activity, extra screen time, or a special treat.

4. Positive Reinforcement Calendar

A Positive Reinforcement Calendar is a visual tool that allows children to track their progress and receive positive reinforcement. Each day, children can mark their achievements or acts of kindness on the calendar. Parents can offer praise and encouragement for these actions, fostering a sense of accomplishment and reinforcing positive behavior over time.

5. Family Appreciation Jar

The Family Appreciation Jar promotes gratitude and positive interactions within the family.

Instead of focusing on individual behavior, family members can write notes expressing appreciation for one another and place them in a jar. Regularly reading and reflecting on these notes helps create a supportive and loving family environment, fostering good behavior through mutual appreciation.

Incorporating Positive Messages into Your Family’s Tradition

Despite the Elf on the Shelf controversy, families can still use it to spread kindness and teach responsibility.

• Have the elf perform acts of goodwill to foster kindness toward others.
• Encourage children to take responsibility for their actions with a daily “good deed” challenge from the elf.

Create your own meaningful version by brainstorming fun activities that align with your family’s values.

Adapting Elf On The Shelf To Reflect Cultural Diversity And Values

Parents from diverse backgrounds are finding ways to adapt Elf On The Shelf to better reflect their cultural values and beliefs, such as selecting a more diverse range of elf dolls or creating inclusive stories around their family’s little elf.

• Choose culturally representative elves.
• Create inclusive stories around your family’s little elf.

Is Elf on the Shelf Right for Your Family?

Deciding whether to embrace the Elf on the Shelf can be a polarizing topic, so it’s important to consider your family’s values and beliefs before jumping on the bandwagon.

• Assess your values: Reflect on what matters most to your family when deciding if this Christmas tradition aligns with your holiday celebrations.
• Respect others’ choices: Remember that every family has their own unique approach to the holidays, so it’s essential to respect differing opinions about Elf on the Shelf.
• Consider religious affiliations: If religion plays a significant role in your family’s holiday traditions, make sure Elf on the Shelf doesn’t conflict with those beliefs.
• Get creative: If you do decide to adopt Elf on the Shelf, have fun with it and come up with creative ways to incorporate the mischievous little elf into your daily routine.
• Don’t feel pressured: Don’t feel like you have to participate in Elf on the Shelf just because everyone else is doing it. Do what feels right for your family.

FAQs

Is Elf on the Shelf a bad idea?

Elf on the Shelf can be a fun holiday tradition, but it’s not for everyone – consider your family’s values and beliefs before starting.

Why are they banning Elf on the Shelf?

There is no widespread ban, but some parents and educators have concerns about its impact on children’s behavior and privacy. Additionally, some TikTok’ers have alluded to a ban by Walmart which is false. And a judge in Georgia issued a joke ban on Elf on the Shelf as a way to help overworked parents.

Does the Elf on the Shelf watch you?

According to the story, elves watch over young children during the day and report back to Santa at night, but this can be adapted to fit your preferences.

How do you get rid of the evil Elf on the Shelf?

If a naughty elf becomes an issue, retire it by explaining to your child why it must leave or replace it with a more positive alternative like Kindness Elves.

How does Elf on the Shelf work?

Elf on the Shelf is a worldwide phenomenon. But for many kids and teens, the lines can blur between innocent holiday traditions and reality. So, are Elf on the Shelf real or fake?

As a beloved Christmas tradition for many families worldwide, the Elf on the Shelf phenomenon has captured imaginations and stirred controversy in equal measure.

In this blog post, we will delve into the origins of this captivating elf tradition and examine how your scout elf is believed to communicate with Santa Claus himself and fly home to the North Pole nightly between Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve.

We’ll explore both sides of the debate – from those who wholeheartedly embrace the magical powers of these mischievous little helpers to skeptics questioning their authenticity or even think the whole elf movement is evil.

As we discuss parental perspectives and challenges surrounding nightly elf movements and social media pressures, you’ll gain insight into some controversial incidents involving elves that have made headlines.

Finally, we’ll consider why “Are elf on the shelf real or fake” continues to be such a hot topic as we look at its enduring popularity, impact on global Christmas traditions, spin-off products like elf pets, and other merchandise.

Table of Contents:

• The Elf on the Shelf Phenomenon
• Controversial Incidents Involving Elves
• FAQs
  • Is The Elf on the Shelf real or do your parents move it?
  • Does Elf on the Shelf watch you?
  • How do you start an Elf on the Shelf tradition?
  • Why was Elf on the Shelf recalled?
• Conclusion

The Elf on the Shelf Phenomenon

Get ready to welcome the Elf on the Shelf, the Christmas tradition that has taken the world by storm since 2005.

The tradition started with a children’s book; The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition. It is a 2005 American picture book for children, written by Carol Aebersold and her daughter Chanda Bell and illustrated by Coë Steinwart.

Aebersold’s twin sister Christa Pitts and her company the Lumistella Company, then took over the production and marketing of the project and the rest is history.

Origins of Elf on the Shelf

The Elf on the Shelf was inspired by Carol Aebersold’s family tradition involving an elf named Fisbee who would mysteriously change locations throughout their home during December.

The book also comes with a new elf doll who then gets its magic after the child at its new home gives it a name.

How Scout Elves Communicate with Santa Claus

Scout elves use Christmas magic to travel back and forth between your home and Santa’s workshop, ensuring they can relay important information about whether kids have been naughty or nice all year long. They love to report on good behavior. But they also report on bad behavior too although the elves themselves are known to be naughty.

But once Christmas day rolls around, the elf is gone until next year.

For those who want to learn more about this beloved tradition, check out my article on Can Elf on the Shelf Move? (Reasons & ideas for why and how).

Believers vs Skeptics

Some kids swear by the magic of Elf on the Shelf, while others scoff at the idea of a lifeless toy having supernatural powers or being able to communicate with Santa.

• Believers: Kids who buy into the Christmas magic love searching for their elf each morning and eagerly await its return from reporting to Santa.
• Skeptics: Older children may question the plausibility of a toy having magical abilities, leading them to doubt its authenticity.
• Critics: Some argue that using Elf on the Shelf as a disciplinary tool instills fear in children instead of promoting the joy of the holiday season.

Despite the debate, Elf on the Shelf remains a popular tradition in many households during the holidays, and some parents even arrange for Elves to get married!.

(Source – Pinterest)

Parental Perspectives and Challenges

While kids love the Elf on the Shelf, parents can find it tough to keep up with nightly elf movements and other holiday responsibilities, leading some to turn to social media for inspiration.

• Social media pressures: Parents may feel the need to keep up with elaborate setups posted by others, adding stress during an already busy season.
• Nightly elf movements: Remembering to move the elf each night can be a daunting task, especially when trying to avoid repetition and maintain their child’s belief in Christmas magic.
• Belief in Christmas magic: Parents may go to great lengths to keep their child’s belief in Santa and the magic of Christmas alive, including using the Elf on the Shelf tradition.

But the hardest job of a parent with regards to Elf on the Shelf is undoubtedly both remembering to move the elf each night, but also to come up with fun, easy-to-execute, mischievous Elf on the Shelf ideas each night too.

But if your kid wakes up the next morning and your elf hasn’t moved to a new spot, you’re in trouble!

Controversial Incidents Involving Elf on the Shelf

A recent Reddit post highlighted anger after the tutor of a fourth grader accidentally revealed that Elf on-the-Shelf is fake.

While some agree it wasn’t appropriate for teachers to reveal this information, others defend educators providing honest responses when asked directly by curious students about different family traditions surrounding Christmas time.

• Teachers’ roles in maintaining belief: Some argue that educators should support parents in preserving the magic of childhood and not disclose the truth about these holiday customs.
• Balancing honesty and preserving childhood innocence: Others believe children deserve truthful answers from trusted adults, even if it means shattering their illusions about magical elves reporting to Santa Claus.
• Elf on-the-Shelf alternatives: For those looking for a new holiday tradition, there are plenty of other options such as Kindness Elves or Reindeer in Here.
• Psychological impact of Elf on-the-Shelf: Some experts argue that the elf can create unnecessary stress and anxiety for children, as they feel constantly monitored and judged by the elf’s presence.
• Elf on-the-Shelf merchandise: The elf has become a commercialized phenomenon, with various merchandise available for purchase including clothing, accessories, and even a movie.

FAQs

Is The Elf on the Shelf real or do your parents move it?

Does Elf on the Shelf watch you?

No, Elf on the Shelf does not actually watch you, it’s just a toy designed for fun and entertainment during Christmas time.

But the premise behind the toy is that your elf keeps an eye on you and reports back to Santa each night as to whether you were naughty or nice.

How do you start an Elf on the Shelf tradition?

To start your own Elf on the Shelf tradition, purchase an official elf from their website or authorized retailers like Amazon or Target, and follow the instructions in the accompanying book.

CLICK HERE to check out all the options on Amazon.

Why was Elf on the Shelf recalled?

There have been no recalls involving The Elf On The Shelf products, but if any recalls occur in the future due to safety concerns or manufacturing defects, information will be available through official channels such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission.

That being said, there were some TikTok’ers who posted about a supposed Walmart recall and also a judge in Georgia who made a joke ruling about banning Elf on the Shelf for the benefit of parents.

But again, no legitimate recall has taken place as of the time of this writing, nor would it be likely.

Conclusion

As a parent or spouse, it’s important to respect others’ choices and feelings regarding this phenomenon.

Whether you choose to adopt an elf or not during the Christmas season, remember that love, kindness, generosity, and joy are what truly matter.

I have a collection of free printable Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize it with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there’s a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.

Elf on the Shelf is a holiday tradition centered around an Elf whose magic is brought to life when a child names it. And each night they supposedly fly home to the North Pole. But can Elf on the Shelf move?

As you embark on this magical journey of creating unforgettable memories for your family, it’s essential to understand the intricacies behind this beloved Christmas tradition. In this blog post, we will dive deep into the world of scout elves and their mysterious movements.

From learning how to make your elf on the shelf work its magic to understanding the official rules that govern these delightful creatures, our comprehensive guide will provide you with creative ideas and solutions for any potential hiccups along the way.

Curious about catching your elf in action? We’ll share some tips on how to catch them moving without breaking any sacred Christmas magic rules. Don’t fret if you’re left wondering why your elf didn’t stir one night – we’ve got the solutions!

So join us as we explore every aspect of whether Elf on the Shelf can move and unlock all there is to know about this enchanting tradition that has captured hearts worldwide.

Table of Contents:

• How to Make Elf on the Shelf Move
• The Official Rules of Elf on the Shelf
• How to Catch Elf on the Shelf Moving
• Why Didn’t My Elf on the Shelf Move?
• FAQs
  • Does the Elf on the Shelf Really Move or is it Your Parents?
  • Why Can’t Elf on the Shelf Move?
  • What Happens if Your Elf on the Shelf Doesn’t Move and You Didn’t Touch It?
• Conclusion

How to Make Elf on the Shelf Move

Alright, let’s dive in.

Making your Elf on the Shelf move is a fun and creative way to bring joy to your family during the holiday season. This beloved shelf tradition has been around for years, and it’s no wonder why. The scout elves that come to visit are known for their mischievous ways and for bringing Christmas magic to homes all around the world.

So, how do you make it happen?

Step #1: Wait until everyone is asleep, especially those curious little ones.

Step #2: Choose a new spot for your elf that will surprise and delight your kids when they wake up the next morning. Get creative with it. Maybe your elf is hanging from the ceiling fan or sitting on top of the Christmas tree.

Step #3: Use props or create scenes with other toys for an extra touch of magic. Maybe your elf is having a tea party with Barbie or playing a game of cards with Woody and Buzz.

Short on ideas?

In a recent article, I have compiled DOZENS of simple, fun, and mischievous Elf on the Shelf ideas you can implement nightly that won’t take a ton of time, or energy, or require you to buy things you don’t already have on hand.

Just click that link to read it on my site.

TIP: To avoid touching the elf directly and risking its magical powers, use kitchen tongs or wear gloves while moving it.

With these simple steps, you can keep the ideas fresh and exciting for your family all season long. And who knows, maybe your elf will surprise you one day and fly back to the North Pole for a quick visit with Santa before returning to your home. Happy elfing.

My son is starting to ask questions about Elf on the Shelf. He was like, “Mommy and Daddy, I think you move the elves every night because they’re always places you can reach.”

Challenge accepted son.

HOW’S THAT FOR CHRISTMAS MAGIC, BUDDY? pic.twitter.com/7GN3bhZF83

— Steve ???? (@NFTbark) December 10, 2021

The Official Rules of Elf on the Shelf

Alright, let’s dive into some elf business.

To ensure a fun and magical experience with your Elf on the Shelf , it’s important to understand and follow the rules from the official Elf on the Shelf website.

So, here are the official Elf on the Shelf rules:

1. No touching: Remind your kids not to touch their scout elf. Your elf is “real” and it may lose its magic powers from the North Pole.
2. Moving every night: Your little elf will move to a different spot each night after reporting back to Santa about who made the nice list that day. But they do report not only on best behavior but also bad behavior.
3. Talking is optional: Elves usually don’t talk but can listen well; however, you can decide if your family’s elf has speaking abilities or not.
4. A name is essential: Give your Elf on the Shelf a unique name so that it receives its Christmas magic and becomes part of your family tradition. It’s the naming that turns it from a toy into a magic elf.
5. Farewell until next year: Your elf will return to Santa Claus at the North Pole on Christmas Eve night to rest up for another holiday season.

By following these simple guidelines, you’ll create an unforgettable Christmas tradition with lots of laughter and memories in store. Now go ahead and have some festive fun with your cleverly positioned elves.

Wondering what the right age is to start or stop this tradition?

Well, the official rules say one thing, but as a parent of three, I have a different opinion. So in a recent article, I break down the very best ages to both start and stop the Elf on the Shelf tradition, including the 1 thing I guarantee you should NOT do.

Just click that link to read it on my site.

How to Catch Elf on the Shelf Moving

As a parent, you know how exciting it is to see the look of wonder on your child’s face during the holiday season. One way to add to that magic is by participating in the popular Elf on the Shelf tradition.

But have you ever wondered if your elf is really moving around at night? If so, you’re not alone. Many parents have asked the same question. In fact, some cynical parents have even called the Elf on the Shelf tradition evil!

So, can Elf on the Shelf move? The answer is yes. Scout elves are known for their ability to fly back to the North Pole each night to report to Santa. When they return, they often move to a new spot in the house to continue their shelf work.

If you want to catch your elf in action, here are a few tips:

• Tip #1: Set up a surveillance camera, like a smartphone or tablet, in the room where your elf is located. Make sure it’s hidden well.
• Tip #2: Be patient. Elves usually move when everyone is asleep, so try staying up late or waking up extra early to catch them off guard.
• Tip #3: Create an enticing environment by placing treats or small toys near their current spot as bait for their next move.

Remember, catching your elf in the act can be a thrilling experience for both you and your kids. However, it’s important to keep the magic alive by not spoiling the tradition for younger children who still believe wholeheartedly in Christmas magic.

Why Didn’t My Elf on the Shelf Move?

Every morning during the Christmas season, children eagerly search for their elf’s new spot. But sometimes, they might find their little scout hasn’t moved at all. Don’t worry; there are a few possible explanations for this.

Bad Weather Conditions

Sometimes, bad weather can prevent your elf from making its nightly trip to the North Pole and back. This can be due to heavy snowfall or even a severe storm. So, if your elf hasn’t moved, it’s possible that the weather conditions were too harsh for it to fly back.

Elf Needs a Little Help

If you accidentally touched your elf, it could lose its magic temporarily. To help restore its magic powers, sprinkle a little cinnamon next to it before bedtime – elves love cinnamon. This will help your elf regain its strength and continue its shelf work.

Creative Solutions When Your Elf Doesn’t Move

• A note: Leave a note from your elf explaining why it couldn’t move. This can be a fun way to keep the Christmas magic alive and explain the situation to your child.
• Kitchen tongs: Use kitchen tongs to carefully move your elf to a new spot. Just be sure to avoid touching it with your hands.

Remember: Elves Are Unique.

Every elf is unique, and they all have their own personalities and ideas. So, if your elf doesn’t move one night, don’t worry. It’s all part of the shelf tradition, and there are plenty of other shelf ideas you can try. Just remember to have fun and enjoy the Christmas magic with your family.

Wife: OMG! I forgot to move the Elf on the Shelf! Can you move it for me?!

Me: No problem, babe. I got you.#WrestlingDads #RoH #RingOfHonor #FinalBattle @jaybriscoe84 #DemBoys #TheBriscoes @MariaLKanellis @RealMikeBennett @MattTaven #HonorPals pic.twitter.com/QlwNHJipXA

— Beau G. Bowden (@beaugbowden) December 12, 2021

FAQs

Does the Elf on the Shelf Really Move or is it Your Parents?

The Elf on the Shelf doesn’t actually move by itself. Parents are responsible for moving and posing the elf each night to create a fun and magical experience for their children during the holiday season.

Why Can’t Elf on the Shelf Move?

The Elf on the Shelf is a toy, and the elf’s hands are sewn together so it cannot physically move by itself. It relies on parents to reposition it every night while kids sleep, simulating its movement from reporting back to Santa Claus at the North Pole.

What Happens if Your Elf on the Shelf Doesn’t Move and You Didn’t Touch It?

If an Elf on the Shelf hasn’t moved, there could be several reasons: perhaps parents forgot or were too busy that day. To maintain belief in magic, they might explain that sometimes elves take breaks or stay put due to weather conditions affecting their trip back from the North Pole.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Elf on the Shelf can move if you follow the official rules and get creative with your ideas.

There are many ways to make your elf appear as though it has come alive, from using fishing line to setting up a zip line. However, if your elf didn’t move, don’t worry – there could be several reasons why.

Remember that Elf on the Shelf is meant to bring joy and excitement during the holiday season for children and adults alike. So have fun with it and enjoy this magical tradition!

I have a collection of free printable Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize it with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there’s a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Image by Jill Wellington from Pixabay

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.

Our family loves Elf on the Shelf. But with 3 kids of a wide age range, I wondered what age is Elf on the Shelf good for?

Elf on a Shelf is officially created for kids between 36 months and 15 years. However, many kids as young as age 2 enjoy the holiday tradition, and many kids over age 10 begin to lose interest after they stop believing in Santa Claus.

But there’s a lot more to know about the Elf on the Shelf phenomenon, ages, when to start the tradition and when to stop it.

There are some great ways to introduce your elf to your kids and some heartfelt ways to say goodbye when they begin to age out of it.

Let’s explore!

What is Elf on the Shelf?

Unless you’ve been living under a rock or don’t have kids, you’ve surely heard of Elf on the Shelf.

It’s both an elf doll and also a companion children’s book called The Elf on the Shelf: A Christmas Tradition, first published in 2004 by Carol Aebersold and her daughter Chanda Bell and illustrated by Coë Steinwart. You can buy the doll/book combo almost anywhere when it’s the holiday season, including Target, Wal-Mart, and, of course, Amazon.

The idea is that the elf was sent to your house from Santa to help keep an eye on your kids. Each night they fly home to the North Pole and then return just before daybreak.

For us poor parents, that means we have to find a creative new place to move the elf to once the kids go to bed, and coming up with fun ideas each night.

It’s also a big no-no to ever touch your elf in front of your kids (who after all think the elf is real). That makes them sick and they temporarily lose their magic (giving you a much-needed night off from moving your elf).

Traditionally the elf would show up the day after Thanksgiving, and then go away the evening of Christmas Eve. Sometimes parents have their elf show up throughout the year for their kid’s birthdays.

What’s the point of Elf on the Shelf?

The point of Elf on the Shelf is to add another layer of innocence to the Christmas holiday season. Young children all over the world already believe in Santa Claus, so Elf on the Shelf is just a natural extension of that.

Your little elf flies home to the North Pole every night to report back to Santa on your child’s good behavior.

For the cynics, the “evil” elf is basically a marketing creation. Someone invented the idea in 2004 as a way to sell dolls, books, DVDs, and accessories.

Of course, many traditions were probably started by marketers looking to generate sales, so that’s not really unusual.  Also, like a lot of traditions, it eventually became ingrained in the hearts of kids and parents everywhere.

Our older daughters used to race downstairs every morning during the holiday season to see where Cookie had moved to.  They would talk to Cookie and be convinced that Cookie was as real as you and I.

My wife and I did sometimes tire of having to create new fun things to do with the elf every night. So much so that I compiled a list of 31 Mischievous Elf on the Shelf Ideas.

Just click that link to see my article.

My point in that article was to come up with really fun things to make your elf do, BUT to also make them quick and easy for tired parents.

So check them out if you need some inspiration.

Keep the Cheer Here! Annual Elf on the Shelf Program. https://t.co/t2vFrfk7eh pic.twitter.com/6VISljQIsT

— AssabetValleyChamber (@AsVaCC) November 2, 2020

How does Elf on the Shelf arrive for the first time?

As the book tells us, when your family buys an Elf on the Shelf and names it, that’s when it comes to life through the miracle of Christmas magic. Then the elf flies to the North Pole each night to update Santa Claus on your kids.

After you buy your elf (typically done without your kids), your elf arrives the day after Thanksgiving. But whatever day you decide to decorate your tree works also.

You would name your elf to instill magical powers and bring it to life and then read the book to your kids. That night, after the kids go to bed, your elf would “fly” home to the North Pole and then return in the morning before the kids wake up.

That’s your cue to move the elf to a new position once they are asleep.

Elf on the shelf. I hid the first one, here are the rules! Let the games begin!#mwdec2019 @plymouthhd2762 @slarkins64 @brandi_vorhoff @PareeWills @jenscibs pic.twitter.com/HeQp58KFvr

— Gabrielle Tellez (@Briella2762HD) December 19, 2019

What are the rules for Elf on the Shelf

The 2 simple rules for Elf on the Shelf are to never touch your elf when your kids are around and the elf is supposed to fly home to the North Pole each night and then land in a new spot in your home before morning.

Of course, you can add or make up your own rules; this is just for fun, after all.

But there are 2 general rules most elf owners go by, so if your kids talk about their elf with their friends, it’s good to not stray too wildly from the core fundamentals.

1. Don’t touch your elf – The elf loses his or her magic when touched by hands. Some people claim the elf loses its magic “forever” but in our house, that’s a bit extreme, so we say for a day. If you do have to move the elf, it’s great to use kitchen tongs or some tool to avoid hand contact.
2. The elf moves every night to a different spot– This is important for the storyline of the elf updating Santa. Of course, unless you are perfect, there WILL be some night where you’re tired and forget to move it. In those cases, we tell our kids that Cookie must be sick, and then the next day she makes a miraculous recovery.

If you do accidentally touch the elf with your hands, since they lose their magic for a day, you get the night off on moving it. Then the next night, it would be back to elf business as usual.

The Elf on the Shelf FAQ page also makes the following suggestions for helping your elf’s magic to return after accidentally being touched:

• Write a note to your elf or Santa – Apologize for touching the elf and ask for the magic to be restored
  
• Sprinkle some cinnamon around your elf! Cinnamon naturally boosts your elf’s energy enough to fly home so they can see the North Pole doctor
• Sing Christmas carols to your elf – If you’ve seen the movie Elf you know how much Christmas spirit recharges Santa’s sleigh. It works the same on your elf.

Otter lovers know what Thanksgiving means…the return of Ottnot (Oscar, Ogden, and Oakley’s Elf On The Shelf). Ogden is busy reviewing the “rules”. pic.twitter.com/veqoryIlnc

— KY Wildlife Center (@Kywildliferehab) December 1, 2019

Is there an age limit for Elf on the Shelf?

Officially, the Elf on the Shelf company says, that their product is for kids between age 3 and age 15. But “officially”, scout elves aren’t supposed to get married, but many parents do arrange wedding ceremonies.

In truth, most 15-year-olds will have long stopped believing in Santa and will probably think that Elf on the Shelf is lame and for little kids. But for the young at heart, children of all ages can have fun with it if they aren’t too cynical.

My older 2 daughters, ages 15 and almost 16 as of this writing, both no longer believe in Santa and were pretty disinterested in our elf last few Christmas seasons. But since my youngest daughter was only 5 years old, she’s fully into it.

I also think you could start Elf on the Shelf at age 2 rather than 3, although certainly, ages 3-7 is probably the sweet spot.

When should you start Elf on the Shelf?

The company recommends age 3, but I think age 2 works also.

Once kids hit age 2, they are really noticing a lot, are naturally curious, and get excited about cool things. That child-like innocence is in full-effect too, so the holiday season becomes a magical time.

I will say that while age 2 is a fun age to start, they may not have the attention span to sit through the reading of the book, and they probably won’t grasp all the rules and general concepts.

But it will still be fun to start and it will set the stage for the next year.

What age do you stop Elf on the Shelf?

I definitely saw a lack of interest during the Christmas season when my older girls were ages 10 and almost 12.

Their friends had all started to tell them Santa wasn’t real. When that happened, all of the childhood legends from the Easter Bunny to the Tooth Fairy and our elf Cookie all started to not be interesting anymore.

So while the company officially says age 15 year olds as the top end, I personally think that’s way too old.

The only exception I would make is if there are still younger siblings in the house. That is true in our case, so we will definitely keep doing it for our youngest daughter Layla.

Now that the cat’s out of the bag with the older girls, hopefully, this coming holiday season we’ll get them in on the action, and that might make them interested again from a different perspective.

So I would say 10 or 11 would be about the maximum age kids will still be interested in Elf on the Shelf. But whenever they learn the truth about Santa should be about right.

Elf on the Shelf Printables: Fun for All Levels of Elfing Families
Customize Your Elf Fun with a Behavior Meter, Scavenger Hunt, Goodbye Letter, and Planning Calendar https://t.co/HwC0TkccZz pic.twitter.com/vQB00LhBbK

— Tammy Gnagy (@MacKidLouEast) November 13, 2019

How to write a goodbye note from Elf on the Shelf

An Elf on the Shelf goodbye letter is crucial for the end of each holiday season, as scout elves are supposed to be gone by Christmas day.

But you might also want to write one when your elf is leaving for good as your kids have gotten old enough to not be as interested anymore.

Remember, this is a letter to your kids from your elf. Elves are known for being a little funny and mischievous, so your letter should reflect that.

Of course, the final letter your elf writes could be more heartfelt as it’s certainly a sad occasion when you close the door on that level of childhood innocence.

I have a collection of free printable Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters (5 seasonal and 2 final) you can download for FREE!

They are in Microsoft Word, that way you can personalize it with your elf’s name and also address them to your kids if you wish.

Use a cool font for your Elf on the Shelf goodbye note

Assuming you’ll write the letter on your computer and print it, I recommend using a sort of funky, hand-written looking font.

You may have some great ones, but there’s a ton of free ones you can download too. Since this will be during the holiday season, you could also use some holiday-themed fonts too.

Here are my favorite free fonts for Elf on the Shelf goodbye letters

(just click to download them for free from the font website):

• Frosty
• Chocolate Covered Raindrops
• Cinnamon Cake
• Going To Do Great Things

Like most fonts you would download online, these are zip files. Just right click to expand and then drag the folder contents into your fonts folder (that for a PC; I’m not super familiar with Mac).

Final thoughts

In this post, we took a quick look at the Elf on the Shelf tradition.

Elf on the Shelf can bring joy and excitement to younger children during the holiday season, regardless of their age, but the sweet spot is between the ages of 3 and 8.

This fun and interactive elf toy keeps the holiday spirit alive in a unique and engaging way.

As a newer tradition, it has become a cherished part of many a family tradition, lighting up children’s faces with delight. To learn more about this enchanting tradition and find ideas for incorporating the elf into your holiday festivities, visit the official Elf on the Shelf website.

Embrace the magic and create lasting memories with this beloved holiday companion and family member.

Middle Class Dad is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you click to Amazon from my site and choose to make a purchase. This is no way increases the cost to you.